Apple Butter

Preparation info
  • Makes

    3 cups

    • Difficulty

      Easy

Appears in
The Four Horsemen: Food and Wine for Good Times from the Brooklyn Restaurant

By Nick Curtola, Gabe Ulla, James Murphy and Justin Chearno

Published 2024

  • About

This is a very silky and vibrant sauce made from apples that I like to have on hand in the wintertime. Contrary to the title, the sauce contains no dairy—“butter” is more of a nod to its smooth and rich consistency, à la “peanut butter.” I prefer Honeycrisp apples for this, but I’ve also had good success with the Fuji and Gala varieties.

Use this apple butter where you would normally use applesauce. It’s also great with salty and harder cheeses, such as clothbound Cheddars, as well